OpenAI o3 Looks at GPT-2 Through the Logit Lens
I read the paper Dissecting Recall of Factual Associations in Auto-Regressive Language Models by Geva et al., and I highly recommend it. If you’re curious about how large language models process information internally, this paper is a must-read, along with some of the references it cites.
Inspired by this paper, I used the logit lens technique to inspect the GPT-2 model with the following simple code:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
# Run the model to obtain hidden states from all layers
with torch.no_grad():
outputs = model(**model_inputs, output_hidden_states=True)
hidden_states = outputs.hidden_states # Tuple: (embeddings, layer1, layer2,...)
# Get the LM head weight matrix to project hidden states to vocab space.
# Note: GPT2 ties the LM head with the input embedding weights.
lm_weight = model.get_input_embeddings().weight # shape: (vocab_size, hidden_dim)
# Get original token IDs and corresponding tokens from the prompt.
token_ids = model_inputs["input_ids"][0].tolist()
orig_tokens = processor.convert_ids_to_tokens(token_ids)
print("Original tokens:", orig_tokens)
print("")
# For each layer (including initial embeddings as layer 0), compute and print top3 predictions.
for layer_idx, hs in enumerate(hidden_states):
# hs shape: (batch_size, seq_length, hidden_dim)
# Compute logits by projecting the hidden states onto the vocabulary space.
logits = torch.matmul(hs, lm_weight.T) # shape: (batch, seq_len, vocab_size)
# Get the top k predictions for each token.
topk = torch.topk(logits, k=10, dim=-1)
# Prepare top k tokens for each token position.
topk_tokens = []
for pos in range(topk.indices.shape[1]):
top_ids = topk.indices[0, pos].tolist()
top_tokens = processor.convert_ids_to_tokens(top_ids)
topk_tokens.append(top_tokens)
print(f"Layer {layer_idx}:")
for pos, orig_tok in enumerate(orig_tokens):
print(f" Token '{orig_tok}': top3 -> {topk_tokens[pos]}")
print("")
I used the example from the paper “Beats Music is owned by”, and the results are:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
Original tokens: ['Be', 'ats', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġis', 'Ġowned', 'Ġby']
Layer 0:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['Be', 'Bey', 'Bee', 'Beg', 'Beat', 'ĠBe', 'BE', 'Ę', 'ĠãĤµãĥ¼ãĥĨãĤ£', 'č']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ats', 'ATS', 'atz', 'atsu', 'atted', 'aten', 'atsuki', 'atts', 'atri', 'aths']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'Music', 'music', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠMUS', 'ĠMusical', 'ĠSongs', 'ĠAudio', 'ĠConcert', 'ĠPiano']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġis', 'Ġisn', 'Ġhas', 'Ġdoes', 'Ġwas', 'Ġwill', 'Ġseems', 'Ġdoesn', 'Ġcomes', 'Ġcan']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'owned', 'Own', 'ĠOwn', 'Ġowns', 'ĠOWN', 'Ġowning', 'ĠOwners', 'Ġownership', 'Owner']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'by', 'ĠBy', 'ĠBY', 'By', 'Ġthrough', 'Ġin', 'Ġfrom', 'Ġat', 'Ġvia']
Layer 1:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['lyak', 'hemoth', 'gr', 'har', 'ĠEdited', 'achy', 'gra', 'cham', 'ab', 'grim']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['chet', 'ake', 'ats', 'orney', 'afety', 'chers', 'hop', 'ĠKats', 'olid', 'omo']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠCube', 'ĠCircus', 'ĠMachine', 'Ġsinger', 'ĠCro', 'Ġvenue', 'ĠCafé', 'ĠGrill']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġmounted', 'ĠBalt', 'Ġtopped', 'Ġbacked', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġsandwic', 'Ġoverseen', 'Ġrun', 'Ġnow', 'Ġslated']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'swick', 'ĠDominion', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġownership', 'Ġowning', 'Ġowner', 'ĠOW', 'Ġowners', 'Ġowns']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'ĠNorman', 'ĠPall', 'Ġlaw', 'Ġhand', 'ĠGat', 'Ġdragging', 'ĠIB', 'Ġpressing', 'Ġstaging']
Layer 2:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['ab', 'achy', 'cca', 'lyak', 'hemoth', 'ached', 'gr', 'har', 'aker', 'aum']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['chet', 'hop', 'chers', 'cha', 'iki', 'ake', 'omo', 'hey', 'ons', 'Ġburned']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCube', 'ĠFabric', 'ĠMachine', 'ĠGrill', 'Ġestablishments', 'ĠArchitects', 'hop', 'Ġdownstairs', 'ĠNob', 'ĠCircus']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'ĠBalt', 'Ġpressed', 'Ġmounted', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġpainted', 'Ġsandwic', 'Ġtopped', 'Ġserved', 'Ġbacked']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'ĠDominion', 'Ġproperty', 'swick', 'Ġstationary', 'ĠOW', 'Ġstaggered', 'Ġdeb', 'ĠLyon', 'Ġbutcher']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'Ġpressing', 'Ġstaging', 'ĠNorman', 'ĠKab', 'Ġwise', 'Ġlaw', 'ĠFlore', 'Ġdragging', 'ĠGladiator']
Layer 3:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['cca', 'aum', 'ached', 'ab', 'hemoth', 'gotten', 'achy', 'har', 'lyak', 'gged']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['hop', 'iki', 'rail', 'hma', 'chers', 'Ġorganized', 'hey', 'Ġburned', 'ons', 'cha']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCube', 'ĠFabric', 'hop', 'ĠMachine', 'ĠArchitects', 'Ġvenue', 'ĠNob', 'Ġsting', 'Ġestablishments', 'Ġsound']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'Ġbacked', 'ĠBalt', 'Ġmine', 'Ġpainted', 'Ġpressed', 'Ġmounted', 'Ġorganized', 'ĠCube', 'Ġcentered']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠDominion', 'Ġstationary', 'Ġartisan', 'Ġdeb', 'Ġowner', 'Ġunpredictable', 'Ġcamp', 'Ġbaker']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'Ġhand', 'Ġwise', 'Ġbar', 'ĠNorman', 'ĠGladiator', 'Ġpressing', 'law', 'ĠGat', 'Ġlaw']
Layer 4:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['aum', 'cca', 'hemoth', 'har', 'ached', 'ats', 'lyak', 'gged', 'heading', 'ijing']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['hop', 'iki', 'hey', 'rail', 'chet', 'hee', 'Ġorganized', 'hma', 'yon', 'hit']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'ĠCube', 'hop', 'ĠArchitects', 'ĠMachine', 'ĠMom', 'ĠNob', 'ĠWond', 'Ġdownstairs', 'Ġestablishments']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'Ġpainted', 'Ġmine', 'Ġpressed', 'Ġbacked', 'Ġwise', 'ĠBalt', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġstruck', 'Ġnot']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'Ġfancy', 'ĠDominion', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġbaker', 'Ġartisan', 'Ġhotel', 'Ġserv', 'ĠAB', 'Ġchilled']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'Ġhand', 'ĠGladiator', 'Ġwise', 'law', 'Ġlaw', 'ĠNorman', 'Ġpressing', 'ĠGat', 'ĠDrill']
Layer 5:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['gotten', 'hemoth', 'har', 'ijing', 'aum', 'ached', 'avers', 'gged', 'aver', 'gging']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['hop', 'chers', 'cher', 'ĠLogged', 'iki', 'chet', 'hey', 'hee', 'ay', 'Ġproud']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'hop', 'ĠCube', 'ĠMom', 'Ġsting', 'ĠMachine', 'ĠWond', 'ĠStyles', 'ĠArchitects', 'ĠNob']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġnot', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġpainted', 'Ġserved', 'Ġpressed', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġbacked', 'Ġsold', 'Ġorganized', 'ĠGarland']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['ĠDominion', 'ĠAB', 'Ġbaker', 'Ġowned', 'Ġeditor', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġsworn', 'aband', 'Ġhotel', 'Ġstationary']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'ĠGladiator', 'law', 'Ġhand', 'ĠNorman', 'Ġlaw', 'Ġpressing', 'ĠChef', 'Ġwise', 'ĠDrill']
Layer 6:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['gotten', 'avers', 'aum', 'hemoth', 'ijing', 'gging', 'aver', 'har', 'agher', 'heading']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['hop', 'ĠLogged', 'chet', 'cher', 'hee', 'Ġproud', 'chers', 'iki', 'ons', 'hen']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'ĠCube', 'hop', 'ĠMom', 'Ġsting', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠSphere', 'ĠStyles', 'ologist', 'ĠWond']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġthrilled', 'Ġnot', 'Ġpainted', 'ĠBree', 'Ġnow', 'Ġbacked', 'ĠGarland', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġpressed']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġlucky', 'Ġowned', 'ĠDominion', 'Ġsworn', 'ĠTravis', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġoutright', 'ĠMarina', 'aband', 'Ġstationary']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'law', 'Ġpressing', 'Ġhand', 'ĠGladiator', 'ĠNorman', 'ĠChef', 'Ġlaw', 'ĠGat', 'Ġwise']
Layer 7:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['gotten', 'ijing', 'agher', 'gging', 'aum', 'hemoth', 'avers', 'har', 'heading', 'vest']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠLogged', 'hop', 'cher', 'hee', 'chet', 'ĠDynam', 'Ġproud', 'ons', 'Ġdrum', 'Ġdear']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'hop', 'ĠCube', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠStyles', 'Ġwise', 'ĠNob', 'ĠMom', 'ĠSounds', 'ĠGrill']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġthrilled', 'Ġpressed', 'Ġpleased', 'ĠGarland', 'Ġsold', 'Ġnot', 'Ġbacked', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġpainted', 'Ġserved']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'ĠTravis', 'Ġserv', 'Ġlucky', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġoutright', 'Ġby', 'ĠMarina', 'Ġhands', 'Ġsworn']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠGarland', 'Ġpressing', 'law', 'Ġhand', 'Ġcraft', 'Ġmag', 'Ġlaw', 'ĠCraft', 'ĠNorman', 'ĠChef']
Layer 8:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['clips', '://', 'agher', 'Cola', 'milo', 'Initialized', 'wcsstore', 'Iterator', 'ĠTradable', 'æĸ¹']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠLogged', 'hop', 'ĠDynam', 'cher', 'Ġproud', 'hen', 'yon', 'iron', 'Ġak', 'Ġdear']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'hop', 'ĠCube', 'ĠScene', 'ĠStyles', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠGrill', 'ĠCircus', 'ĠClub', 'Ġwise']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġthrilled', 'Ġsold', 'Ġnot', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġhonored', 'ĠSOLD', 'Ġabsolutely', 'Ġproud']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['ĠTravis', 'Ġowned', 'Ġby', 'Ġoutright', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠAngelo', 'ĠSpark', 'aband', 'ĠBY', 'ĠDominion']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġproprietary', 'Ġcraft', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġhand', 'Ġpressing', 'Ġcamp', 'law', 'ĠGarland', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġselling']
Layer 9:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'agher', 'wcsstore', 'Cola', "Ġ'/", 'Initialized', 'dates', ':{', 'ideshow']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'ĠLogged', 'hop', 'cher', 'hen', 'Ġak', 'ĠDry', 'yon', 'Ġproud', 'iron']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠCube', 'ĠScene', 'ĠStyles', 'ĠSounds', 'hop', 'ĠBox', 'ĠClub', 'ĠBreak']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġsold', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġslated', 'Ġnot', 'Ġhonored', 'ĠSOLD', 'Ġsupposed']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['ĠTravis', 'Ġowned', 'Ġoutright', 'Ġby', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠAngelo', 'ĠEqual', 'Ġentirely', 'ĠSpark', 'Ġinternationally']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġproprietary', 'law', 'Ġcraft', 'Ġpressing', 'Ġcamp', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġhosting', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġhand', 'Ġrenting']
Layer 10:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'agher', 'wcsstore', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'Cola', 'ideshow', 'dates', 'Ġaddr']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'ĠLogged', 'cher', 'chet', 'Ġak', 'hop', 'hen', 'Ġdear', 'hered', 'Ġproud']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'ĠCube', 'ĠCircle', 'Ġwise', 'ĠScene', 'ĠClub', 'ĠMachine', 'Ġstation', 'ĠSpotlight', 'ĠBox']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġorganized', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġslated', 'Ġsold', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġhonored', 'Ġobviously', 'Ġbacked', 'Ġsupposed']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['ĠTravis', 'Ġowned', 'Ġby', 'Ġoutright', 'Ġtrademark', 'ĠEqual', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠAngelo', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġindependent']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġproprietary', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġhosting', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġrenting', 'law', 'Ġhand', 'ĠGarland', 'Ġcraft']
Layer 11:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', 'agher', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'ideshow', 'office']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'ĠLogged', 'chet', 'Ġpowder', 'cher', 'mith', 'ĠDrum', 'hop', 'Ġweld', 'Ġdragging']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠFabric', 'ĠCube', 'ĠScene', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠBox', 'Ġwise', 'ĠClub', 'Ġstation', 'ĠCards', 'Ġclip']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġobviously', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġalways', 'Ġsold', 'Ġslated', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġhonored', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġnot']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'ĠTravis', 'ĠAngelo', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġentirely', 'Ġoutright', 'ĠMiranda', 'Ġowned', 'ĠEqual']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġproprietary', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġcamp', 'Ġauction', 'Ġhosting', 'Ġpressing', 'Ġcraft', 'Ġindependent']
Layer 12:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'agher', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'ideshow', 'office']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'hop', 'hare', 'chet', 'ĠSlave', 'ign', 'mith', 'ĠDrum', 'ĠFabric', 'tons']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCube', 'ĠScene', 'ĠFabric', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠArchitects', 'Ġstation', 'ĠClub', 'ĠEater', 'ĠBreak', 'Ġclip']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġobviously', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġsold', 'Ġalways', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġnow', 'Ġslated', 'Ġproud', 'Ġthrilled']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'ĠTravis', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġoutright', 'ĠAngelo', 'Ġproperty', 'by', 'ĠEqual', 'Ġequally']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġproprietary', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġcamp', 'Ġprivate', 'Ġlocal', 'Ġpowerful', 'Ġpolice', 'Ġcraft']
Layer 13:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'ideshow', 'office']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'hare', 'hop', 'ĠDrum', 'hit', 'kept', 'up', 'ĠDanger', 'mith', 'Ġdragging']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠScene', 'ĠCube', 'ĠFabric', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠClub', 'ĠBreak', 'ĠArchitects', 'Ġclip', 'ĠEater', 'Ġwise']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġorganized', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġobviously', 'Ġsold', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġalways', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġset', 'Ġslated']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġwholly', 'by', 'Ġoutright', 'Ġequally', 'Ġentirely', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠAngelo', 'Ġexclusively']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġproprietary', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġtrademark', 'ĠScha', 'Ġrights', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠGall', 'ĠConst']
Layer 14:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'office']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'hare', 'hop', 'up', 'ĠDR', 'ĠDrum', 'mith', 'leep', 'ĠSong', 'ĠFabric']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠScene', 'ĠClub', 'ĠFabric', 'ĠCube', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠArchitects', 'ĠCL', 'ĠBreak', 'Ġclip', 'ĠCards']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġorganized', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġsold', 'Ġobviously', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġorganised', 'Ġalways', 'ĠCube']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġwholly', 'by', 'Ġequally', 'Ġoutright', 'Ġexclusively', 'ĠDominion', 'Ġinternationally', 'ĠPete']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġlicensed', 'Ġproprietary', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġlicense', 'ĠJ', 'ĠConst', 'ĠLicensed', 'Ġorganizers']
Layer 15:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDynam', 'ĠDR', 'ĠDeath', 'ĠSlave', 'mith', 'ĠSong', 'ĠDrum', 'Ġdeath', 'ĠDanger', 'Ġwise']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠClub', 'ĠScene', 'ĠCL', 'ĠHall', 'ĠArchitects', 'ĠBreak', 'ĠCircle', 'ĠCafe', 'ĠCube', 'ĠCD']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġorganized', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġsold', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġobviously', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġorganised', 'Ġslated', 'ĠCube']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'by', 'ĠTyler', 'ĠDominion', 'ĠTravis', 'ĠPete', 'ĠSaga', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġequally']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġlicensed', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġproprietary', 'ĠLicensed', 'Ġresponsible', 'ĠScha', 'Ġdrill', 'ĠConst']
Layer 16:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDeath', 'ĠDynam', 'ĠDR', 'hare', 'ĠSong', 'Ġdeath', 'heet', 'mith', 'Ġpoll', 'ĠSlave']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠScene', 'ĠClub', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠCenter', 'ĠCD', 'ĠCDs', 'ĠStudio', 'ĠHall', 'ĠCards', 'Ġvideo']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġsold', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġobviously', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġnotoriously', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġnow', 'Ġalways', 'Ġset']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġtrademark', 'Ġby', 'Ġexclusively', 'ĠPete', 'by', 'ĠTravis', 'ĠSaga', 'Ġproperty', 'ĠMiranda', 'ĠTyler']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġtrademark', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġpowerful', 'ĠJ', 'ĠLicensed', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġassociation', 'Ġheavy', 'Ġproprietary']
Layer 17:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDeath', 'ĠDynam', 'up', 'Ġdeath', 'ĠDR', 'ĠSlave', 'heet', 'leep', 'mith', 'Ġpoll']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠClub', 'ĠScene', 'ĠCD', 'ĠStudio', 'ĠFabric', 'ĠCenter', 'ĠCards', 'ĠVideo', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠCircle']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġsold', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġobviously', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġalways', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġsupposed', 'Ġhonored', 'Ġowned']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġtrademark', 'Ġby', 'Ġexclusively', 'by', 'ĠPete', 'ĠSaga', 'ĠMiranda', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġentity']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġlicensed', 'ĠJ', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġmaster', 'Ġpowerful', 'ĠLuc', 'Ġlicensing', 'ĠDavid', 'ĠJack', 'ĠClive']
Layer 18:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDeath', 'ĠDR', 'ĠDynam', 'Ġdeath', 'ĠSlave', 'Ġoff', 'up', 'ĠDrum', 'mith', 'ĠD']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠClub', 'ĠCD', 'ĠScene', 'ĠCenter', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠCards', 'ĠFabric', 'ĠStudio', 'ĠVideos', 'ĠSpotlight']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġowned', 'Ġsold', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġhonored', 'Ġorganized', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġnotoriously', 'Ġobviously']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġtrademark', 'Ġby', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġentity', 'ĠPete', 'by', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġowned', 'ĠSaga']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġlicensing', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġlicensed', 'ĠLuc', 'Ġbankrupt', 'ĠBrooklyn', 'ĠJ', 'Ġmaster', 'ĠCu']
Layer 19:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠDeath', 'mith', 'ĠDynam', 'ĠNap', 'Ġdeath', 'ĠSlave', 'heet', 'Ġoff', 'ĠDR', 'up']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠClub', 'ĠCD', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠStudio', 'ĠScene', 'ĠSpotlight', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠCafe', 'ĠCube', 'ĠVideos']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġowned', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġnotoriously', 'Ġhonored', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġsold', 'Ġunderstandably', 'Ġproud']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'ĠSaga', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġentity', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġowned', 'by', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġsubsidiaries']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġbankrupt', 'Ġlicensing', 'ĠCu', 'Ġpublishing', 'Ġlicensed', 'ĠLuc', 'ĠJ', 'Ġprivate', 'Ġsister']
Layer 20:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'TEXTURE', 'Ġanyway', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'up', 'hop', 'ĠDeath', 'heet', 'Ġdeath', 'Ġoff', 'leep', 'ĠDrum', 'ob']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCD', 'ĠClub', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠCDs', 'ĠSpotlight', 'ĠCafe', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠCube', 'ĠDisco', 'Ġalbum']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġowned', 'Ġunderstandably', 'Ġnotoriously', 'Ġsold', 'Ġproud', 'Ġhonored', 'Ġalways']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġtrademark', 'Ġby', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'ĠSaga', 'Ġentity', 'Ġowned', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġinternationally', 'Ġexclusively']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġbankrupt', 'Ġpublishing', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġsister', 'Ġlicensed', 'ĠMeredith', 'ĠJ', 'ĠJewish', 'Ġprivate']
Layer 21:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'TEXTURE', 'Ġanyway', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['up', 'mith', 'heet', 'ĠDeath', 'hop', 'leep', 'Ġdeath', 'Ġoff', 'Ġup', 'ĠDrum']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCD', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠCDs', 'ĠCafe', 'ĠCube', 'ĠClub', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠCompany']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġowned', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġsold', 'Ġnotoriously', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġproud', 'Ġnow', 'Ġhonored']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġtrademark', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġby', 'Ġowned', 'Ġentity', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'ĠSaga', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġexclusively']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġpublishing', 'Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġbankrupt', 'Ġparent', 'Ġprivate', 'Ġformer', 'ĠJ', 'Ġlicensed', 'ĠJewish', 'Ġlicensing']
Layer 22:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['heet', 'mith', 'up', 'hop', 'ĠDeath', 'hift', 'worth', 'ĠDrum', 'leep', 'Ġdeath']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCD', 'ĠCube', 'ĠVideo', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠCafe', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCDs', 'ĠClub', 'ĠCompany', 'Ġstore']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġsold', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġlocated', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġnotoriously']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġby', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġowned', 'Ġentity', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġnotoriously', 'ĠSaga']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġparent', 'ĠJ', 'Ġbillionaire', 'Ġbankruptcy', 'ĠUS', 'Ġpublishing', 'ĠRupert', 'Ġformer', 'Ġbankrupt', 'ĠCharles']
Layer 23:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'heet', 'hift', 'up', 'ĠDeath', 'hop', 'kins', 'worth', 'leep', 'Ġdeath']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCube', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠClub', 'ĠCD', 'ĠInc', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠCorporation', 'ĠFoundation', 'ĠCDs']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġsold', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġalso', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġannounced']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġowned', 'Ġentity', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġproperty']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġparent', 'Ġbillionaire', 'Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġconglomerate', 'ĠRupert', 'Ġbankrupt', 'ĠCharles', 'ĠJ', 'ĠCoca', 'Ġsister']
Layer 24:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'heet', 'hift', 'up', 'leep', 'ĠDeath', 'ome', 'kins', 'pring', 'ĠUp']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠVideo', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠCube', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠClub', 'ĠCD', 'ĠStore', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠInc', 'ĠVideos']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġnow', 'Ġalso', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġannounced', 'Ġsold', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġcurrently']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġowned', 'Ġentity', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġconglomerate']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġbillionaire', 'Ġconglomerate', 'ĠRupert', 'Ġparent', 'ĠJ', 'Ġformer', 'Ġbankrupt', 'Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsister']
Layer 25:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġaddr', 'Ġanyway', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'heet', 'up', 'hift', 'ĠDeath', 'ĠUp', 'leep', 'Ġdeath', 'Ġmustache', 'pring']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠClub', 'ĠVideo', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠCD', 'ĠStore', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠInc', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠSpotlight']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġowned', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġannounced', 'Ġalso', 'Ġsold', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġnow', 'Ġhosting']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġowned', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġentity', 'Ġrights', 'Ġlicensed']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġbillionaire', 'Ġconglomerate', 'ĠRupert', 'Ġparent', 'Ġformer', 'Ġbankruptcy', 'Ġpublishing', 'ĠCharles', 'ĠUS', 'ĠJ']
Layer 26:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'agher', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'heet', 'Ġguitar', 'hift', 'ĠUp', 'up', 'ĠDrum', 'Ġdrum', 'Ġup', 'Ġmustache']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠVideo', 'ĠStreaming', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠClub', 'ĠInc', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠCD', 'Ġstreaming']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnered', 'Ġowned', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġannounced', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġalso', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġnow', 'Ġpartnering']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġowned', 'Ġentity', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġlicensed', 'Ġconglomerate']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġbillionaire', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġformer', 'Ġpublishing', 'ĠRupert', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġparent', 'ĠSony', 'Ġcorporate', 'ĠUS']
Layer 27:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', 'TEXTURE', '.(']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'heet', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠUp', 'hift', 'ome', 'ĠGuitar', 'up', 'ĠDrum', 'Ġup']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠEntertainment', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠInc', 'Ġvideo', 'ĠCEO', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠStreaming', 'ĠCD', 'ĠClub', 'ĠDisco']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnered', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġowned', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġalso', 'Ġofficially', 'Ġannounced']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġowned', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġentity', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġconglomerate']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġbillionaire', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġformer', 'ĠBroad', 'ĠSony', 'Ġcompany', 'ĠRupert', 'Ġpublishing', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġparent']
Layer 28:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'wcsstore', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', '.(', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠMusic', 'heet', 'Ġguitarist', 'ĠGuitar', 'ĠUp', 'pring', 'ĠDrum', 'ĠRhythm']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠEntertainment', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠStreaming', 'ĠInc', 'ĠVideo', 'Ġvideo', 'Ġstreaming', 'ĠCompany', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠCD']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnered', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġowned', 'Ġofficially', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġalso', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġannounced']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġowned', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġentity']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['Ġconglomerate', 'Ġbillionaire', 'ĠSony', 'Ġformer', 'ĠBeats', 'Ġcompany', 'Ġcompanies', 'ĠRupert', 'ĠAOL', 'Ġparent']
Layer 29:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', ':{', 'wcsstore', "Ġ'/", 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', '.(', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġguitarist', 'ĠGuitar', 'ĠAudio', 'ĠRhythm', 'pring', 'Ġrecording', 'ĠRecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠEntertainment', 'ĠStreaming', 'Ġstreaming', 'ĠVideo', 'ĠCEO', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠInc', 'ĠVideos']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnered', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġowned', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġofficially', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġalso']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġowned', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġcompany', 'Ġlicensing']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġbillionaire', 'Ġcompany', 'ĠSony', 'Ġcompanies', 'Ġformer', 'ĠRupert', 'ĠSamsung', 'ĠApple']
Layer 30:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', ':{', 'wcsstore', "Ġ'/", 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', '.(', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'ĠElectronics', 'ĠGuitar', 'ĠRhythm', 'Ġdrum', 'ĠVideo']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠStreaming', 'Ġstreaming', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠVideos', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠVideo']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnered', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġalso', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġowned', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġofficially', 'Ġlicensing']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġowned', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġproperty', 'by']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSony', 'ĠApple', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġbillionaire', 'ĠSamsung', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġcompanies', 'ĠRupert', 'ĠAdidas']
Layer 31:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', ':{', 'wcsstore', "Ġ'/", 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'ĠGuitar', 'ĠRhythm', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠRecording', 'ĠiPhone']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'Ġstreaming', 'ĠInc', 'ĠStreaming', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠEntertainment', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġapp', 'Ġalbum']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnering', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġnow', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġalso', 'Ġowned', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġofficially']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġowned', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġcompany', 'Ġlicensing']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠApple', 'ĠSony', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠSamsung', 'Ġconglomerate', 'Ġcompanies', 'Ġbillionaire', 'Ġcompany', 'ĠAlibaba']
Layer 32:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'ĠRhythm', 'ĠGuitar', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠiPhone', 'Ċ']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'Ġstreaming', 'ĠStreaming', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġapp', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠEntertainment', 'Ġalbum']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnering', 'Ġnow', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġalso', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġofficially', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġreleasing', 'Ġdelighted']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġowned', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġlicensing', 'Ġcompany']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠApple', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠSony', 'ĠSamsung', 'Ġbillionaire', 'ĠPepsi', 'ĠAlibaba', 'Ġcompanies', 'Ġconglomerate']
Layer 33:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', ':{', "Ġ'/", 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġheadphones', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠAudio', 'ĠRhythm', 'ĠGuitar', 'ĠRecording', 'ĠDrum']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠStreaming', 'Ġstreaming', 'Ġalbum', 'ĠEntertainment', 'Ġapp']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpleased', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġnow', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġreleasing', 'Ġalso', 'Ġpartnered', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġdelighted', 'Ġofficially']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġowned', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġcompany', 'Ġprivately']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'ĠSony', 'ĠSamsung', 'Ġbillionaire', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠPepsi', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠAlibaba']
Layer 34:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', 'Ġaddr', '.(', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['mith', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġheadphones', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠRhythm', 'ĠRecording', 'ĠGuitar', 'Ġrecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠMusic', ',', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠStreaming', 'Ġstreaming', 'Ġapp', 'Ġalbum']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġpartnering', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġreleasing', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġalso', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġnow', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġdelighted']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġowned', 'Ġtrademark', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġexclusively', 'by', 'ĠBY']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠApple', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠSony', 'ĠSamsung', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠPepsi', 'ĠAlibaba', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġrapper']
Layer 35:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', '.(', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'mith', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġaudio', 'ĠRecording', 'ĠRhythm', 'Ġrecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġalbum', ',', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġapp', 'ĠBillboard']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġdelighted']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġowned', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġtrademark', 'by', 'ĠBY']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'ĠSony', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠSamsung', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠPepsi']
Layer 36:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', '.(', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'Ġmusic', 'mith', 'Ġaudio', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠRhythm', 'Ġlistening', 'ĠRecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġalbum', ',', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠBillboard', 'Ġapp']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġalso', 'Ġproud', 'Ġoffering']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġexclusively', 'by', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġowned', 'Ġwholly', 'ĠBY']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠSony', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠSamsung', 'ĠGrammy']
Layer 37:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', '.(', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'Ġmusic', 'mith', 'Ġaudio', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġlistening', 'Ġrecording', 'ĠRhythm']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠInc', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠSpotify', ',', 'Ġalbum', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġhas', 'Ġapp']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġalso', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġproud', 'Ġoffering']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġowned', 'by', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġand']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'ĠKanye', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠSony', 'ĠGrammy', 'ĠiTunes']
Layer 38:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'wcsstore', 'Ġanyway', '.(', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'Ġaudio', 'mith', 'Ġguitar', 'ĠRhythm', 'Ġlistening', 'Ġrecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠMusic', ',', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠInc', 'Ġalbum', 'Ċ', 'Ġhas', 'Ġmusic']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġalso', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġproud', 'Ġoffering', 'Ġthrilled']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'by', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġowned', 'Ġand', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġproperty']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'ĠKanye', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠSony', 'ĠGrammy', 'ĠiTunes']
Layer 39:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'Ġanyway', 'wcsstore', '.(', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', 'TEXTURE']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'Ġaudio', 'mith', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġlistening', 'Ġrecording', 'ĠRhythm']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠBeats', 'Ċ', 'ĠInc', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġhas', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġis', 'Ġand']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġalso', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġnow', 'Ġproud', 'Ġa']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġexclusively', 'by', 'Ġand', 'Ġowned', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġproperty']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'ĠKanye', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠSony', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠiTunes', 'ĠGrammy']
Layer 40:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", ':{', 'Ġanyway', 'wcsstore', '.(', 'Ġaddr', 'agher', '._']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ġmusic', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġheadphones', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġaudio', 'mith', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġlistening', 'Ċ', 'Ġrecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCEO', ',', 'ĠBeats', 'Ċ', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġis', 'Ġhas', 'ĠInc', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġand']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġpleased', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġa', 'Ġthrilled', 'Ġproud']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġand', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġexclusively', 'by', 'Ġowned', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġproperty']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠKanye', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠiTunes', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠDJ', 'ĠSony']
Layer 41:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', "Ġ'/", 'Ġanyway', ':{', 'wcsstore', '.(', 'Ġaddr', '._', 'agher']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ġmusic', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġheadphones', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġaudio', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġtracks', 'Ġlistening', 'Ċ', 'Ġrecording']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠCEO', 'ĠMusic', ',', 'Ċ', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġalbum', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġis', 'ĠInc']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġoffering', 'Ġa', 'Ġexpanding', 'Ġpleased']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġand', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġowned', 'Ġsubsidiaries', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġprivately']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠApple', 'ĠiTunes', 'Ġrapper', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠDJ', 'ĠSony']
Layer 42:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'Ġanyway', "Ġ'/", ':{', '.(', 'wcsstore', 'Ġaddr', '._', 'agher']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ġmusic', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ġheadphones', 'Ġaudio', 'Ċ', 'Ġguitar', 'Ġtracks', ',', '-']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> ['ĠCEO', ',', 'ĠBeats', 'Ċ', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġhas', 'Ġis', 'Ġand', 'ĠSpotify', "'s"]
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġa', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġoffering', 'Ġthe', 'Ġbringing']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġowned', 'Ġprimarily', 'Ġproperty', 'Ġin']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠBeats', 'ĠApple', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠiTunes', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠDJ', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠSony']
Layer 43:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'Ġanyway', "Ġ'/", ':{', '.(', 'wcsstore', 'Ġaddr', '._', 'agher']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ġmusic', 'ĠMusic', 'ĠAudio', 'Ċ', 'Ġheadphones', ',', 'Ġaudio', ':', '-', 'Ġby']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'ĠCEO', 'Ċ', 'Ġhas', 'Ġis', 'Ġand', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠMusic', "'s", 'Ġwill']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġreleasing', 'Ġa', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġnow', 'Ġalso', 'Ġpartnering', 'Ġthe', 'Ġnot', 'Ġgearing', 'Ġbringing']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġin', 'Ġsubsidiary', 'by', 'Ġprimarily', 'Ġprivately']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠApple', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠiTunes', 'ĠKanye', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠDJ', 'ĠSony', 'ĠMusic']
Layer 44:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'Ġanyway', "Ġ'/", '.(', ':{', 'wcsstore', 'Ġaddr', '._', 'agher']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ċ', 'Ġby', ',', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠMusic', ':', '-', 'Ġ1', 'ĠAudio', '.']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'Ċ', 'ĠCEO', 'Ġis', 'Ġhas', 'Ġand', "'s", '.', 'Ġwill', 'Ġ(']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġa', 'Ġthe', 'Ġreleasing', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġnot', 'Ġan', 'Ġone', 'Ġmaking']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġin', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġexclusively', 'ĠBy', ',', 'by', 'Ġwholly', 'Ġprimarily']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠApple', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠUniversal', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠiTunes', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠSony', 'ĠRd', 'ĠDisney']
Layer 45:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'Ġanyway', "Ġ'/", '.(', ':{', 'Ġaddr', 'wcsstore', '._', 'agher']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ċ', ',', 'Ġ1', ':', '-', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġ2', 'Ġand']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'Ċ', 'Ġis', 'Ġhas', 'Ġand', 'ĠCEO', "'s", '.', 'Ġ(', 'Ġwill']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġa', 'Ġthe', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġnot', 'Ġreleasing', 'Ġone', 'Ġan', 'Ġlaunching', 'Ġmaking']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġin', 'Ġjointly', ',', 'ĠBy', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġthe', 'Ġa', 'Ġprimarily']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠApple', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠSpotify', 'ĠUniversal', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠiTunes', 'ĠRd', 'ĠSony', 'ĠKanye', 'ĠDisney']
Layer 46:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['://', 'clips', 'Ġanyway', "Ġ'/", '.(', 'Ġrespectively', 'hire', "'re", 'Ġaddr', '":"']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['Ġby', ',', 'Ċ', '-', ':', 'Ġ1', 'ĠMusic', 'Ġmusic', 'Ġper', 'Ġ2']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'Ċ', 'Ġis', 'Ġand', 'Ġhas', '.', 'Ġ(', "'s", 'ĠCEO', 'Ġwill']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġa', 'Ġthe', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnot', 'Ġnow', 'Ġone', 'Ġan', 'Ġmaking', 'Ġno', 'Ġreleasing']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġin', ',', 'Ġthe', 'Ġjointly', 'Ġa', 'ĠBy', 'Ġexclusively', 'Ġfirst']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠApple', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠUniversal', 'ĠSpotify', 'Ġrapper', 'ĠDisney', 'ĠSony', 'Ġmusic', 'ĠDr', 'ĠRd']
Layer 47:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['Ġa', 'Ġthe', ',', '.', 'Ċ', '-', 'Ġin', 'Ġsure', 'Ġ"', 'Ġand']
Token 'ats': top3 -> [',', 'Ġby', 'Ċ', ':', '-', 'Ġ1', '.', 'Ġand', 'Ġis', 'Ġper']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'Ċ', 'Ġis', 'Ġand', 'Ġhas', '.', 'Ġ(', "'s", 'Ġwill', 'Ġin']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġa', 'Ġthe', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnot', 'Ġone', 'Ġnow', 'Ġan', 'Ġin', 'Ġ"', 'Ġgoing']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġin', ',', 'Ġthe', 'Ġa', 'Ġfirst', 'Ġor', 'Ġ(', 'Ġas']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠApple', 'ĠUniversal', 'ĠDr', 'Ġthe', 'ĠBeats', 'ĠDisney', 'ĠIn', 'ĠSony', 'ĠE', 'Ġmusic']
Layer 48:
Token 'Be': top3 -> ['Ġsure', 'Ġa', 'ijing', 'ep', 'au', 'ak', 'arers', 'gan', 'aver', 'Ġcareful']
Token 'ats': top3 -> ['ĠMusic', 'Ġby', ':', 'Ċ', ',', 'Ġ1', '.', '/', 'ĠAudio', 'ĠBy']
Token 'ĠMusic': top3 -> [',', 'Ċ', ')', 'Ġis', '.', 'Ġhas', 'Ġand', "'s", 'Ġ(', ':']
Token 'Ġis': top3 -> ['Ġa', 'Ġthe', 'Ġan', 'Ġalso', 'Ġnow', 'Ġone', 'Ġnot', 'Ġcurrently', 'Ġin', 'Ġowned']
Token 'Ġowned': top3 -> ['Ġby', 'Ġand', 'Ġin', ',', 'Ġor', '/', 'Ġa', 'Ġthe', 'Ġ(', 'Ġjointly']
Token 'Ġby': top3 -> ['ĠApple', 'ĠIn', 'Ġthe', 'ĠUniversal', 'ĠDr', 'ĠE', 'ĠRd', 'Ġa', 'ĠJimmy', 'ĠJay']
I feel I could spend hours to figure out something meaningful out of this, therefore I gave the newly released OpenAI o3 model a try, and its answer really impressed me! Below is the copy pasted full answer. Maybe you find it interesting and useful too.
1. Token-wise Analysis
a. Be
+ ats
: Subword recomposition
Depth | Top Predictions | Interpretation |
---|---|---|
0–3 | "Be" , "Bee" , "Beg" / "ats" , "atz" , "atsu" | Just echoing embeddings — early layers reflect lexical similarity |
4–15 | "aum" , "hemoth" / "hop" , "iki" , "hee" | Still treating subwords separately — drifting to phonetically similar words |
~20 | ats → "guitar" , "audio" , "music" | Model begins integrating with rightward context (ĠMusic ) |
28–35 | Both → "Beats" , "headphones" , "Audio" | Fused entity formed — hidden state now encodes the brand |
36–48 | Plateaus — predictions stabilize | High confidence in fused representation |
Insight: Subword recomposition occurs around layers 20–30. Early logit-lens layers reflect surface form only.
b. ĠMusic
: From noun to brand entity
- Layers 0–10:
"Music"
,"Concert"
,"Audio"
– generic, topic-related - Layers 11–25: Shifts to venues and organizations
- From ~25 onward:
"Beats"
becomes top prediction – model has fusedBeats Music
into a single branded concept
c. Ġis
: Syntax to semantics
- Early (0–5):
"is"
,"has"
,"was"
– purely grammatical alternatives - Mid (6–15):
"sold"
,"mounted"
,"delighted"
– verbs relevant to company ownership - Late (20–48):
"pleased"
,"partnered"
,"currently"
– business-centric semantics
d. Ġowned
: Detects “owned by” bigram
- Layers 0–10:
"owned"
,"ownership"
,"owner"
- Layers 11–18: Begins predicting
"by"
as top next token - Layer 18–20:
"by"
becomes dominant — collocation is locked in
e. Ġby
: Fact retrieval happens late
Depth | Top Predictions | Interpretation |
---|---|---|
0–10 | "Garland" , "Norman" , "law" | Generic co-occurrence nouns |
15–25 | "conglomerate" , "subsidiary" | Category identified — model expects org name |
29–48 | "Beats" , "Sony" , Apple | Ground-truth fact retrieved |
Insight: Model only accesses factual knowledge of Beats → Apple in the final 30% of the stack.
2. Phase Transitions (Cross-token View)
Phase | Layers | Characteristics |
---|---|---|
Lexical / Phonological | 0–10 | Surface-form similarity; weak composition |
Syntactic / Collocational | 10–25 | Phrase detection; token fusion; “owned → by” pairing |
Semantic / World Knowledge | 25–48 | Entity linking; factual recall (“Beats is owned by Apple”) |
3. Quantitative Checks You Can Try
✅ KL Divergence to Final Layer
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
from torch.nn.functional import kl_div, log_softmax, softmax
final_logits = logits_all_layers[-1]
kl_vals = []
for l in range(len(logits_all_layers) - 1):
p = softmax(final_logits, dim=-1)
q = log_softmax(logits_all_layers[l], dim=-1)
kl_vals.append(kl_div(q, p, reduction='batchmean'))
✅ Entropy of by
’s Distribution
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
import torch
entropies = []
for l in range(len(logits_all_layers)):
probs = softmax(logits_all_layers[l], dim=-1)
by_probs = probs[0, pos_by] # index of "by"
entropy = -(by_probs * by_probs.log()).sum()
entropies.append(entropy.item())
4. Why Be
Predicts Garbage Early
The token Be
is ambiguous and seen in many noisy contexts:
Be
as a verb → “Be happy”, “Be careful”Be
as part of a URL → “beats://…” leads to predictions like://
,wcsstore
Be
in names → “Beyoncé”, “Bei…”
Conclusion: The model hedges its bets early until later layers clarify context via ats
, Music
.
5. Practical Logit Lens Tips
✅ Early layers reflect form, not meaning
✅ Mid-layers resolve phrase structure & entity fusion
✅ Top layers encode semantic associations & facts
✅ Intervening layers (20–30) are ideal for probing collocations, entity grounding
6. Where to Go Next
- Ablation: Mask attention in layers 25–35 to see if Apple disappears from predictions
- Prompt surgery: Try “Beats Electronics is owned by” — see if factual path changes
- Mean path probing: Project hidden state at
by
onto name vectors — discover if Apple vector activates early
Happy hacking! 🔬📊